The threat of retaliation - in the form of being fired, harassed or moved to a dead end position - is very scary to a younger engineer. But from a rational point of view it's not very strong (HOWEVER many managers or CEOs are far from rational.)
- Firing someone has large costs to the employer. You have the job because you are needed. Same for side-lining someone or not promoting them.
- Firing someone removes the final incentives against that person reporting the deed to the govt. It pushes that person toward reporting instead of softer "negotiated" steps such as continuing to argue for legal alternatives or discussing it with an intermediate rather than outright reporting. And many corporate legal or accounting people are amazing at finding alternative ways to achieve the same result in a not-illegal manner.
- A lawyer can help you much more once there is retaliation. The company might end up fighting both the fraud reporting AND the retaliation.
Just firing someone is not a great "solution" for the company.
Letting you believe that they will ... that's very powerful.
(and probably all this is caveat: in countries where retaliation is illegal enough and commonly taken to court or settled. which is not worldwide.)
- Firing someone has large costs to the employer. You have the job because you are needed. Same for side-lining someone or not promoting them.
- Firing someone removes the final incentives against that person reporting the deed to the govt. It pushes that person toward reporting instead of softer "negotiated" steps such as continuing to argue for legal alternatives or discussing it with an intermediate rather than outright reporting. And many corporate legal or accounting people are amazing at finding alternative ways to achieve the same result in a not-illegal manner.
- A lawyer can help you much more once there is retaliation. The company might end up fighting both the fraud reporting AND the retaliation.
Just firing someone is not a great "solution" for the company.
Letting you believe that they will ... that's very powerful.
(and probably all this is caveat: in countries where retaliation is illegal enough and commonly taken to court or settled. which is not worldwide.)