Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I feel silly to have to defend him again, but you misrepresented what happened. Grossly.

The chief of the UN food program, so most definitely not the EU, claimed that 2% of Musk's wealth would solve world hunger.

Musk invites them to do the math, and would agree to provide such funds if the claim were to be true.

They couldn't produce a sane plan. Instead the idea was to give 40 million people free money, for one year. Which is great, but it's not a sustainable approach or way to "solve world hunger".

So the UN was bluffing and the bluff was called. Musk did not bluff as immediately after, he donated 5.7B of his wealth to an undisclosed charity (on record with the SEC).

I guess this shows the power of narratives. Musk is a rogue character but if there ever was a technical or economical way to solve world hunger, I'd put my money on Musk.



Just to be clear this isn't what happened and is almost a copy and paste of what Musk fans say happened, despite it being literally in the public.


Just to be clear, you didn't say anything, so you're not clear.

The actual tweets, UN claim, and donation are in the open: https://fortune.com/2022/02/15/elon-musk-5-7-billion-donatio...


> I feel silly to have to defend him again

"Have to"? You don't "have" to defend Elon Musk at all, and maybe you should ask yourself what compels you to do something that makes you feel silly. I mean, you do recognize that what you're doing here, defending the reputation of a billionaire, on some level is very silly. He certainly doesn't need your help, so why do you do it?


What compels me is the truth and a sense of justice.

The UN was virtue signaling and playing the greedy billionaire card to guilt trip Musk into being responsible for not solving world hunger, whilst he easily could.

The UN claim was an incompetent bluff, that was called. Hollow words and zero substance. Meanwhile, Musk donated 5.7B.

So yes, when somebody is doing something good for the world, billionaire or not, that truth has to prevail. Same for when said billionaire does something bad.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: