Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Twitter HAS a free speech problem.

No, it doesn't.

> This is not controversial.

If you keep getting in arguments about something, it's pretty silly to claim there is no controversy.

> Now you may not agree that Twitter SHOULD allow free speech

If you don't agree that Twitter should do something that it currently isn't, you by definition don't see it as having a problem in that behavioral domain.

> but you can not deny that censorship exists on Twitter and it is serving the political agenda of some people.

Private actors controlling the use of their private resources to select which ideas they will and will not promote with them is called “free speech”. So, you seem to think Twitter’s problem is that they exercise free speech.



> Private actors controlling the use of their private resources to select which ideas they will and will not promote with them is called “free speech”.

I have to admit that this makes sense. But still kinda disturbing in this case. Because when the private resource we're talking about is Twitter, the actors behind can exercise their right of free speech for mass manipulation. That's too much power. I guess this is the problematic part.

It's not exactly the same thing as the right to free speech of a single individual or a small company.

Your logic is sound, but sometimes scale changes the rules. Especially in this very special case where Twitter has become the digital equivalent of a global town square. That's the catch.

Anyway maybe my quick arguments weren't very good after all.

But do you really not see any problems with Twitter lately? Is everything okay?

You seem smart. I'm genuniely curious.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: