We may well really need this kind of tracing, and frankly it would be useful if we had had it since it would have and will save lives.
Do I think it is sensible to raise concerns? Yes
Am I disappointed that there aren't specific suggestions to address issues? Yes
It is really easy to criticise and a lot more difficult to come up with solutions. As an expert in privacy, I'd have liked to see specific actionable items. e.g. 'Google/Apple must do X to ensure Y' or something saying 'Yes, this is really difficult and I don't know the answer'. This opens the floor for collaboration and for suggestions which feels a lot more constructive.
What's key is that this is done right. If it isn't done right, there's a risk that no one will install it and we don't get the protection.
Do I think it is sensible to raise concerns? Yes Am I disappointed that there aren't specific suggestions to address issues? Yes
It is really easy to criticise and a lot more difficult to come up with solutions. As an expert in privacy, I'd have liked to see specific actionable items. e.g. 'Google/Apple must do X to ensure Y' or something saying 'Yes, this is really difficult and I don't know the answer'. This opens the floor for collaboration and for suggestions which feels a lot more constructive.
What's key is that this is done right. If it isn't done right, there's a risk that no one will install it and we don't get the protection.