Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> user is incentivised to seek the most "premium" treatment

They can "seek" it, but in the public system you don't really have a route for doing that. You might want a CT scan, but if your doctor doesn't think you need it you're not going to get it.

Your list left off (4) queueing. In the UK public system, if your condition is not urgent you'll have to wait, possibly for months. Unless you have private top-up insurance which will cover the specialist you're waiting for.

(It's difficult to estimate how much money the NHS saves by people on queues for non-urgent operations dying from something unrelated in the meantime - e.g. dying of a heart attack while waiting a year for a hip replacement)



Queues are a result of mentioned instruments. Say a hospital has a CT scanner capable of 10 scans per day, 3,5k scans per year. NHS pays for 500. A hospital can fully utilise the scanner and blow their yearly budget of publicly funded scans in two monts, do 10 free scans a week or do 8 scans and save 2 for emergencies. Placing more scanners does not reduce queues.


The CT scanner is usually owned by the NHS trust, which makes the marginal cost of using it rather small. It's almost the other way round: having bought a big capital asset, the incentive is to make sure it's kept busy being used effectively. The NHS "internal market" obfuscates this hugely, but there is still no incentive to over-provision because the system can't drive up external insurance costs.

See e.g. https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RyJfEbwGwgkC&pg=PA4&lpg=...

(random googling found confirmation of this in someone's FOI request: www.heartofengland.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/FOI4797.docx )




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: