Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Can you go into specifics here? I'm not really understanding.

It sounds like a security deposit, of a type. For example, I had to leave one of my shoes at the front counter of a store that hosted a small gaming LAN in the back.



If that's the case then I'm confused as to where the cryptocurrency comes in. A security deposit works just as well with fiat cash as it does with cryptocurrency and in your example there is no money exchanged at all.


Money is only a token of value.

What if you were unable to accept cash (for example, you are on vacation)?

Wouldn't it be useful to make a deposit on a car, right before you use it?

What hasn't been explained here, are what guarantees the depositor receives.


I just don't see how ethereum (or even bitcoin) is useful here. If you make a deposit on a rental vehicle then the deposit will be returned when you return the vehicle as it was given to you. Why is a smart contract needed?


When you do not want to be there to physically collect the deposit?


Certainly a smart contract is not necessary for that.


Can you link to such an implementation?


I'm not really sure what you're asking for. If you're looking for a system capable of accepting payment without an attendant there are many. Here is just one example:

http://bw-2e2c4bf7ceaa4712a72dd5ee136dc9a8-bwcore.s3.amazona...

If this is not the type of device you're talking about please be more specific.


I was thinking of a system that would let you place a deposit immediately before rental (imagine a rental car in a public lot) and then automatically receive your deposit back when you are done with the car (which was possibly even left in a different lot). I'm thinking the car would use its sensor system to detect if any damage might have occurred and if not, it could trigger the return of a deposit as soon as the vehicle is locked.


The system you describe is already possible today without the need for a smart contract.


Can you link to an implementation?

Admittedly, I don't really understand the distinction of a "smart contract". I am only describing the function of the system that there was some confusion over.


Ok. What I'm saying is that the ability to accept and relinquish an automated security deposit does not require a decentralized technology such as ethereum or even bitcoin.

A machine (like the one I linked above) can accept money and dispense money at the discretion of the business rules that determine the appropriate criteria for these operations (via car sensors or whatever).


Yes, but that requires a fixed machine (or a cash lock box on every vehicle?).

Shouldn't I be able to just leave the car anywhere in a city?


> Yes, but that requires a fixed machine (or a cash lock box on every vehicle?).

Of course not. Do it exactly like how rentals work today except in an app instead of in person. Put in your bank card info, a hold is placed on your card, when the vehicle is returned the hold is released and the service fee is charged.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: